Welcome to Dartmouth's most influential daily
Each day, Dartblog and its team of alumni and students bring you news and commentary from Hanover and the world at large. Read our iPhone edition here.
This is an archived post. Please click here to see the latest entries.
NH Attorney General Declines to Investigate Trustee Insider Dealing
After a preliminary review, the NH AG’s Charitable Trust’s Office has declined to investigate the charges leveled against the College’s Board of Trustees in an anonymous memo written by College employees calling themselves The Friends of Eleazar Wheelock. The accusatory missive, dated February 4, was first published publicly in this space on May 21. The group’s charges include the mismanagement of huge sums of Dartmouth money, the receipt of outsized fees, large losses, “pay for play” practices, and an attitude that allowed ten or more Trustees to manage a large portion of the College’s endowment.
Anthony I. Blenkinsop, director of the Office, wrote a letter to the College dated Friday to announce the decision. He noted that the Board had followed all of the formal requirements of NH’s charitable trust laws in making its many investments with firms belonging to or associated with Trustees: the Board had properly published notice of the individual transactions, and Trustees that were to manage parts of the College’s endowment money had properly recused themselves from meetings during which their investment proposals were evaluated.
The AG letter made no note of the fact that more Dartmouth Trustees had a direct interest in managing the College’s endowment than Trustees at all of the Ivy schools other than Brown. On May 31, Reuters reported:
Dartmouth and Brown - two of the eight Ivy League colleges and universities - lead the group in terms of investing their endowments with firms that have business ties to members of their boards of trustees, a review by Reuters of the Ivies’ investment practices found.
In contrast, the endowments of the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard University and Yale University did not disclose any investments with firms that have ties to their trustees.
Blenkinsop did observe — based on the College’s representation — that Trustees managed 13.5% of Dartmouth’s invested funds, a figure that represents approximately $459 million of the $3.4 billion endowment. The friends of Eleazar Wheelock had asserted that the figure was 50% ($1.7 billion). Additionally Blenkinsop’s letter included a paraphrase of information received from the College on the overall performance of the endowment and of the monies handled by Trustees:
This second-to-last sentence is most curious. The endowment as a whole rose only 37% from 2000-2011, after deducting the College’s draw and after adding alumni contributions (see below chart and table). However, Blenkinsop’s calculation seems to have been made, at the College’s behest, for those years “with the exception of 2008.” Why ignore that year? The omission of 2008 seems to me to be analogous to saying something like the 20th century was one of peace and prosperity for France, with the exception of 1914-1918 and 1940-45, which were challenging years for many nations.
In fact, for heavily leveraged hedge funds, 2008 was an utterly disastrous year — far worse than for the market in general — with some of the Trustee’s investment vehicles being close to wiped out. The AG’s office should have pushed somewhat harder in asking the College to disclose the real results of Trustee investments. In the securities industry, fund managers can’t boast about the results in their good years and exclude the poor ones. Gimme a break.
We should recall at this point the endowment’s complete results under this Board and previous ones.
During the 1990-2000 period, Dartmouth’s endowment enjoyed the highest growth in the Ivy League:
In the subsequent eleven years (2000-2011), with much of the endowment in the hands of Trustees and their friends, the endowment had the lowest level of growth in the Ivies.
There is more to this story than the AG’s Charitable Trust Unit is letting on. Perhaps the Trustees did respect the form mandated by the statutes, but one hopes that our public servants keep the spirit of the laws in mind and not just the letter. Blenkinsop and his colleagues could have done a more thorough job in this matter.
Addendum: If you want to look for yourself at the endowment performance of all major colleges and universities, the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO)-Commonfund Study of Endowments for 2011 is here, and the Association’s historic data for schools back to 1990 is here.
Addendum: Trustees Ed Haldeman and T.J. Rogers have written to the Dartmouth community to announce the AG’s decision:
October 18, 2009
When Love Beckoned in 52nd Street
We were at San Francisco’s BIX last evening, enjoying prosecco, cheese, and a bit of music. A full year of inhabitation in Northern California has unraveled to me no decent venue for proper lounging, but…
October 9, 2009
D Afraid of a Little Competish
So our colleague and Dartblog writer Joe Asch informed me that the D has rejected our cunning advertising campaign. Uh-oh. The Dartmouth is widely known as a breeding ground for instant New York Times successes,…
September 4, 2009
How Regents Should Reign
As Dartmouth alumni proceed through the legal hoops necessary to defuse a Board-packing plan—which put in unhappy desuetude an historic 1891 Agreement between alumni and the College guaranteeing a half-democratically-elected Board of Trustees—it strikes one…
August 29, 2009
Election Reform Study Committee
If you are an alum of the College on the Hill, you may have received a number of e-mails of late beseeching your input for a new arm of the College’s Alumni Control Apparatus called…
August 23, 2009
Fare Thee Well, Tom Crady
And now Dean Tom Crady has precipitously announced his departure from the College after only 20 months on the job. How to read this? By way of background, prior to coming to Dartmouth, Crady had…
May 31, 2009
Kangaroo Court, Indeed
In an interview with The Dartmouth, alumni-elected trustee T.J. Rodgers ‘70 explained his reasons for declining to participate in future evaluations of trustees up for “re-election,” namely the “kangaroo court” nature of such discussion in…